Is This Retailer Trustworthy? Australia's First Integrated Discord Retailer Review System
CardTracker now has community retailer reviews for Australian TCG stores, with review scores shown on every retailer alert. How to leave a review, how scores work and how we keep them honest.
Contents
New: Australia's first and only integrated Discord retailer review system. If you have had a positive or negative experience with an order at any of our hundreds of supported retailers, you can now submit a review to help your fellow Aussie collectors. For example, here is the Kmart retailer page, where Kmart reviews now live.
And every retailer now has a review score. From now on, every retailer alert includes the retailer's review score (once the community has provided enough reviews), so it's quick and easy to see whether a small or big retailer is trustworthy to order from, right when you're deciding whether to buy.
⭐ Why we built this
Restock alerts tell you that stock exists. They have never told you whether you should trust the shop it's at. That matters more than it used to: the Australian TCG market now has the big chains, dozens of independent card shops and a long tail of online-only sellers, and a sealed product at a good price is no help if the order never turns up, arrives crushed, or the seller stops replying.
Until now, that kind of knowledge lived in scattered Discord messages and Facebook comments. Now it is attached to the alert itself.
🗣 How to leave a review
There are two ways, and both end up in the same place.
- From Discord. In the Fellowship of the Ping Discord, and in partner servers that run our alerts, open the user panel and press the Review a retailer button. Pick the retailer from the list, or use "Other retailer" to search for a smaller shop. Every retailer alert also has a "Submit your review" link that takes you to the same place.
- From the website. Go to the retailer's page on CardTracker (for example Kmart) and use the review button there. The review form needs you to be signed in to your CardTracker account.
The review is short. You give:
- An overall rating from 1 to 5.
- Shipping, packaging and communication ratings from 1 to 5, or N/A if they don't apply. Bought in store? Mark shipping and packaging N/A.
- Whether you would buy from them again, yes or no.
- An optional comment of up to 500 characters.
You get one review per retailer. If your experience changes, submit again and it updates your existing review instead of adding a second one.
📊 How the score works
A retailer's score is built from the community's reviews: the average overall rating, the average for shipping, packaging and communication, and the percentage of reviewers who would buy again.
To stop one angry or friendly reviewer from defining a shop, a score is only shown once a retailer has at least three reviews. Below that, the alert shows how many reviews there are so far and invites you to add yours. N/A answers are left out of that aspect's average, so a click-and-collect order doesn't drag down a shop's shipping score.
You will see the score in several places:
- On every retailer alert. Discord alerts show the full breakdown with a link to leave your own review. Telegram, WhatsApp and Reddit alerts carry the review line too, in a shorter form on the platforms that are more limited.
- On the retailer's page. Every retailer on CardTracker has a page with its score, the breakdown, and the individual reviews and comments from the community.
🏪 Small shops get extra detail
For specialist and independent retailers, the community can also add two useful facts: whether the shop is physical or online-only, and a link to its Google or Facebook reviews. Those are shown on the retailer's page and in alerts so you can cross-check our community's opinion against a shop's wider reputation. We don't ask for these on the big chains, since everyone already knows what Kmart is.
Live eBay Deals
Sponsored · #ad
SAVE $678.04
Pokémon TCG 30th anniversary Celebrations tin Greninja V-UNION X2)
SAVE $670.39
Pokémon TCG 30th Anniversary Celebrations 5 Packs Booster Tin X 2 🔥 Sealed
Get notified immediately.
Receive alerts when stock is available, so you don't miss out.
Got a single worth protecting? Ark Grading does it in Melbourne, no overseas shipping, no 5-month wait. CardTracker readers get 5% off with code CARDTRACKER.
Grade with Ark →🛡 How we keep it honest
- Reviews are anonymous. Your name is never shown on a review. We store a one-way hash to make sure you only have one review per retailer, not your Discord ID or account details.
- Real accounts only. To review from Discord, your account must be at least 30 days old and not a bot. Website reviews need a signed-in CardTracker account.
- No links in comments. Links are stripped from comments automatically, so reviews can't be used to advertise.
- Anyone can report a review. Reports need a reason (spam, fake, written by the retailer or a competitor, abusive language, personal information, false claims, wrong retailer, or something else). A review that enough separate people report is hidden automatically while it is checked, and our team reviews the reports.
Reviews are opinions written by community members and are not verified purchases. Treat the score as one more signal alongside price, the retailer's own policies and common sense. Our guide to buying Pokemon cards safely online in Australia covers the rest.
✍ Writing a review that actually helps
- Say what happened. "Arrived in 3 days, well packed, matched the listing" is far more useful than "great shop".
- Be specific about problems. Late shipping, items that didn't match the listing, slow replies, refund trouble and how it was resolved are exactly what other collectors want to know.
- Rate each part honestly. A shop can ship fast and communicate badly, and the separate scores let you say so.
- Keep it fair. Stick to your own experience. Personal details, threats and unsupported accusations will be reported and removed.
- Good experiences count too. Small independent shops that do right by collectors deserve the recognition, and a higher score helps their customers find them.
🚀 Get started
Bought from a store we track recently? Take a minute to review it: head to the retailer's page from our retailer directory, or press Review a retailer in the Discord user panel. Then set up CardTracker alerts to see review scores on every restock from here on.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Are retailer reviews on CardTracker anonymous?
Yes. Reviews are shown without your name, and we only keep a one-way hash so each person has one review per retailer.
Can I review any retailer?
You can review any retailer we track, including the big chains and hundreds of smaller shops. Pick it from the list, or use "Other retailer" in Discord to search.
Why doesn't a retailer have a score yet?
Scores appear once a retailer has at least three reviews. Until then, alerts show how many reviews it has and invite you to add yours.
Can I change my review?
Yes. Submit a review for the same retailer again and it replaces your earlier one.
Do I need to be in the Discord to leave a review?
No. You can review from a retailer's page on the website with a CardTracker account. Discord members can also use the Review a retailer button.
A review looks fake or unfair. What do I do?
Use the Report link on the review and choose a reason. Enough separate reports hide it automatically while we look into it.
Are reviews verified purchases?
No. They are community opinions, so use them as one signal alongside everything else you know about a shop.
Live eBay Deals
Sponsored · #ad
SAVE $1200.26
Indonesian - Fusion Arts Pokémon Booster Box Fusion Strike
SAVE $23.04
Pokemon TCG Sword & Shield S9 Star Birth Booster Pack
Explore CardTracker.au
📬 Monthly TCG Updates and Market Recap
Sign up for our mailing list. No spam - just the best deals and local market trends.
Please check your spam folder for the confirmation email!